Our Menu

Farmer's Market Bread

Fresh bakery baguette toasted with garlic butter, fresh tomatoes, parmesan, and blue cheese.

Shrimp Starters

Lighter portions of our shrimp favorites and a side of sauce. Crispy Fried, Coconut Fried, or Grilled (GF).

Peel-n-Eat Shrimp

Large, USA wild-caught pink Gulf shrimp steamed in the shell. Plain Hot or Chilled, Drunken Beer Butter, Spicy Cajun Butter, or Key Lime Sunset Butter. (GF)

1/2 Pound / Full Pound

Louisiana Gator Tail

Bite-sized pieces of real gator marinated, lightly-floured and fried, served with our Cajun remoulade.

Hush Puppies

Sweet corn meal batter fried up crispy, served with a side of our homemade remoulade sauce or honey.

Fried Green Tomatoes

Southern fried in seasoned flour, sprinkled with parmesan and bacon crumbles, served on fresh greens with homemade blue cheese dressing.

Fresh Jumbo Chicken Wings

6 or 12 fresh jumbo wings, naked fried crispy in a dedicated GF fryer, tossed in your choice of signature sauce. Served with celery and house ranch. (GF)

6 Wings / 12 Wings

"Boneless Wings" Chicken Tenders

Fresh white meat chunks, hand-breaded and fried when you order, tossed in one of our wing sauces. Served with celery and house ranch.

Ten Pieces

Raw Oysters on the Half Shell

Brought in fresh daily from the Gulf states, always hand-shucked when you order. With fresh lemon and cocktail sauce. (GF)

1/2 Dozen / Dozen

Fresh Fried Gulf Oysters

Fresh, never frozen, lightly floured and flash fried when you order, with homemade cocktail sauce.

Fried Pickle Chips

An addictive southern treat! Dill chips tossed in seasoned flour, fried crispy, served with ranch dressing.

Calamari

Wild-caught, USA harvest squid tubes and tentacles, cut in house, lightly floured and flash fried, with marinara.

Onion Rings

Hand breaded in crunchy crumbs, fried golden brown, served with a side of our homemade ranch.

Southern Pimento Cheese Spread

Our own recipe featuring cheddar, pimentos and a touch of onion and jalapeno, served with celery sticks and crusty bread slices.

Garden Salad

Fresh chopped romaine, tomato wedges, red onion slices, shredded carrots, sliced cucumbers, and croutons. (GF without croutons)

Small / Large

Caesar Salad

Fresh chopped romaine tossed with shredded parmesan, croutons and creamy Caesar dressing, served with bakery garlic bread.

Small / Large w/ Garlic Bread

Everglades Salad

Homemade Cajun-spiced pecans, bacon crumbles, tomato wedges, sweet red onion, hearts of palm, and blue cheese on fresh romaine. (GF)

Southern Salad

Sweet Florida strawberries and Georgia pecans over fresh romaine, with palm hearts, red onion, croutons, and goat cheese crumbles. (GF)

Southern Style Chowder

Atlantic clams simmered in real cream and butter, with sweet corn, onions, bell peppers, potatoes, and bacon.

Cup / Bowl

Salty Papa's Original Gumbo

Andouille sausage and fresh chicken, with celery, onions, and green peppers in our spicy tomato stock thickened with filé and brown roux, topped with turmeric rice.

Cup / Bowl

Black Angus Steak Burger

A thick 1/2 pound of fresh beef, grilled to order on bakery brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion. (GF without bun)

Bayou Burger

Our 1/2 pound steak burger topped with homemade pimento cheese, fresh jalapenos, bacon, and hand-breaded onion rings.

Chicken Sammy

Fresh, all-natural, boneless breast on brioche with lettuce, tomato, onion. Grilled (GF), Blackened (GF), Southern Fried, or Buffalo.

Atlantic Cod Sandwich

Mild, flaky whitefish lightly fried in crispy crumbs on bakery brioche roll with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and homemade tartar sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Po' Boy

Fresh bakery long roll with crispy-fried Gulf shrimp, fully dressed with chopped lettuce, tomato and homemade Cajun remoulade.

Chicken Breast Po' Boy

Fresh bakery long roll with crispy-fried chicken breast, fully dressed with chopped lettuce, tomato and homemade Cajun remoulade.

Gulf Oyster Po' Boy

Fresh bakery long roll with crispy-fried Gulf oysters, fully dressed with chopped lettuce, tomato and homemade Cajun remoulade.

Clam Strip Po' Boy

Fresh bakery long roll with crispy-fried clam strips, fully dressed with chopped lettuce, tomato and homemade Cajun remoulade.

Southern Fried Chicken & Gravy

Fresh, boneless breast dredged in seasoned flour, fried golden brown, smothered with from-scratch andouille sausage white gravy.

Key West Chicken Bowl

Turmeric rice and black beans, topped with chicken breast sautéed in garlic-shallot butter, garnished with grilled corn relish, fresh tomatoes, red peppers, and green onions. Served with garlic bread. (GF)

Coconut Fried Chicken

Fresh chicken breast floured and crusted with coconut shreds, fried golden brown, served with homemade piña colada sauce.

Chicken & Waffles

Southern fried chicken breast stacked with fluffy waffles, topped with sweet potato fries and served with maple syrup.

Charleston Chicken & Grits

Creamy cheddar cheese grits topped with sautéed chicken, spicy andouille sausage, white wine, peppers, and our signature Low Country seasonings. Regular or Extra Spicy Ghost Pepper. (GF)

Cast Iron Chicken

Fresh chicken breast sliced and sautéed in real butter with fresh tomatoes, shallots, garlic, and herbs, finished with white wine, served over rice or linguine with garlic bread. (GF over rice)

Petite Filet Mignons

Eight ounces of choice tenderloin beef, brushed with garlic butter and grilled to order. (GF)

Steak & Shrimp Grill

Our tender petite filets with a skewer of large shrimp added on the grill. (GF)

Papa's Famous Shrimp & Grits

A big bowl of creamy cheddar cheese grits topped with sautéed pink Gulf shrimp, spicy andouille sausage, white wine, peppers, and our signature Low Country seasonings with garlic bread. Regular or Extra Spicy Ghost Pepper. (GF)

Bacon Wrapped Shrimp

Two skewers of large sweet pink shrimp wrapped in slices of hickory smoked bacon, brushed with sweet barbeque sauce. (GF)

Coconut Fried Shrimp

Large Gulf shrimp lightly floured and coated with shredded natural coconut then fried golden brown, with homemade piña colada dipping sauce.

City Creole Jambalaya

Gulf shrimp, andouille sausage and chicken breast in a rich, spicy tomato stew with celery, peppers, onions, thickened with dark roux, topped with rice and garlic bread. Regular or Extra Spicy Ghost Pepper.

Fried Shrimp

The classic featuring the highest quality "pink gold" shrimp tossed in crispy crunchy bread crumbs and fried to a golden brown, served with homemade cocktail sauce.

Naked Shrimp

The famous taste of authentic Gulf pink shrimp, simply served with our homemade garlic butter. Your choice of grilled or sautéed. (GF)

Mango & Sweet Chili Grilled Shrimp

Gulf shrimp skewers grilled and basted with a sweet chili sauce and real mango chunks. (GF)

Key West Shrimp Bowl

Black beans, rice, corn relish with fresh tomatoes and onions, topped with Gulf shrimp sautéed in butter and fresh lime juice, with garlic bread. (GF)

Cast Iron Shrimp

Gulf shrimp lightly sautéed in real butter with fresh tomatoes, shallots, garlic and herbs, finished with white wine, served over rice or linguine with garlic bread. (GF over rice)

Gulf Oysters

A half pound of large, plump "select" oysters brought in fresh daily from the Gulf states, never frozen, lightly dredged in seasoned flour and flash fried.

Atlantic Sea Scallops

A generous portion of fresh, large, sweet sea scallops. Grilled (GF), Blackened (GF), Pan-Seared, or Fried.

Clams

Fresh Atlantic clam strips tossed in a light dusting of seasoned flour, then flash fried so they're crispy but tender.

Fried Combo Platter

Choice of two selections of shrimp, cod, oysters, or clams hand-breaded when ordered and fried golden brown. Served with homemade tartar and cocktail sauces.

Snow Crab Legs

Full pound of Alaskan/Canadian snow crab with drawn butter and lemon wedges. (GF)

Atlantic Cod "Fish & Chips"

A half pound of mild, flaky whitefish, cut in planks and tossed in crispy breadcrumbs then lightly fried, served with fries, coleslaw and tartar.

Fresh Catches of the Day

Real Florida favorites such as Hogfish and Black Grouper, spear and line caught from Key West to the deep Gulf. Grilled (GF), Blackened (GF), Sautéed (GF), Broiled (GF), or Fried.

Nawlins Style

Your choice of Gulf fish blackened New Orleans style, topped with our homemade creamy Cajun pepper sauce.

Creamy Coleslaw

Fresh cabbage with homemade sweet dressing. (GF)

Hand-Cut Fries

Fresh cut daily, fried in a dedicated fryer. (GF)

Baked Beans

Brown sugar, onions and bacon. (GF)

Cheesy Grits

House recipe with butter and cheddar. (GF)

Garlic Bread

Bakery ciabatta toasted with our recipe butter.

Fresh Vegetable

Sautéed in our real garlic butter. (GF)

Hush Puppies

Golden brown fried cornmeal balls.

Black Beans & Rice

Our turmeric rice with seasoned beans. (GF)

Sweet Potato Fries

Sweet and crispy, dedicated fryer. (GF)

Mashed Potatoes

With real cream and butter (available 4pm). (GF)

Pink Gulf Shrimp

Grilled (GF) or crunchy fried.

Fresh Chicken Tenders

Grilled (GF) or crunchy fried.

Atlantic Cod

Mild whitefish plank, crunchy fried.

Pasta Bowl

Linguine topped with marinara and parmesan.

Hot Dog

Natural, uncured pure beef dog on toasted roll.

Florida Key Lime Pie

Big slice of our homemade pie with real Key West lime juice and heavy cream in a graham cracker crust, with fresh Florida strawberry drizzle and whipped cream.

Whole Pie $25.00 (pre-order)

Mud Puppy

Homemade peanut butter and cream cheese mousse with dark chocolate ganache fudge, served atop a gluten-free brownie with whipped cream and peanut butter cup crumbles. (GF)

Love Boat Ice Cream

Four scoops of our favorite ice cream made locally in Fort Myers, topped with whipped cream. Flavors change daily.

Bottomless Soft Drinks & Tea

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Mr. Pibb, Iced Tea, Sweet Tea, Coffee.

Frozen Fruit Smoothies

All natural fruit purees frozen and topped with whipped cream and fruit. Piña Colada, Banana, Strawberry, or Mango.

Domestic Draft Beer

Yuengling, Miller Lite, Michelob Ultra. Pints or Pitchers.

Craft Draft Beer

Three craft choices daily — ask your server!

Sangrias by the Pint

House wine, muddled fruit, sparkling water, juices and fruit cordials. White Peach Pinot or Cabernet Red Berry.

House Wine by the Glass

Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay, White Zinfandel, Cabernet, Merlot.

The Salty Papa Margarita

Premium tequila and orange liqueur blended with real lime, lemon and orange juices. On the rocks or frozen. Traditional, Strawberry, or Mango.

Kentucky Wildcat

Premium Kentucky bourbon paired with Ale-8 ginger ale, with fresh lime juice.

Snowbirds Frozen Rum Drinks

All natural fruit purees, flavored rums, topped with a dark rum float, whipped cream and fruit. Piña Colada, Banana, Strawberry, or Mango.

Sanibel Key Lime Pie Martini

Spiced rum and orange liqueur with lime juice and sweet cream. A favorite Florida dessert in a glass!

Bayside Bloody Mary

Your choice of premium vodka mixed with our homemade bloody Mary mix.

Blue Mermaid

Coconut rum and blue curaçao with coconut cream and pineapple juice, topped by fruit and dark rum float. Frozen or on the rocks.

Dirty Arnold Palmer

Sweet tea vodka and lemonade, served frosty cold over ice with fresh lemon wedges.

Southern Storm

Dark rum, Ale-8 ginger, lime, and a splash of sugar cane syrup.

Bliss on the Beach

Premium vodka, peach schnapps, orange and cranberry juices on the rocks.

Gator Bayou Water

Green melon and orange liqueurs, vodka and splashes of lemon and Sprite.

Palm Tree Punch

Light and dark rums with orgeat and orange liqueur, lime and simple syrup. The perfect classic island drink!

Small Pupper

Ground beef or cubed chicken breast sautéed with fresh vegetables or rice.

Large Doggo

Ground beef or cubed chicken breast sautéed with fresh vegetables or rice.

Puppuccino

Treat cup of whipped cream.